Nicholson posted first-place finishes on both the 1M and 3M boards against Sarah Lawrence, contributing to the 118-66 win. On the 1M board he sophomore won the event by over 45 points with 171.85 points and on the 3M he also took first with 146.25, winning by almost 30 full points there. For the season, he is 4th on the team with 98 points and his 10 1st-place finishes rank second on the team.